Unsubscribe

Confirm you would like to unsubscribe from this list

Remove strategy

Confirm you would like to remove this strategy from your list

Welcome to Thornburg

Please select your location and role to help personalize the site.
Please review our Terms & Conditions

For Institutional / Wholesale / Professional Clients

The content on this website is intended for institutional and professional investors in the United States only and is not suitable for individual investors or non-U.S. entities. Institutional and professional investors include pension funds, investment companies registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, financial intermediaries, consultants, endowments and foundations, and investment advisors registered under the Investment Advisors Act of 1940.

TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF USE

Please read the information below. By accessing this web site of Thornburg Investment Management, Inc. ("Thornburg" or "we"), you acknowledge that you understand and accept the following terms and conditions of use.

Disclaimers

Products or services mentioned on this site are subject to legal and regulatory requirements in applicable jurisdictions and may not be licensed or available in all jurisdictions and there may be restrictions or limitations to whom this information may be made available. Unless otherwise indicated, no regulator or government authority has reviewed the information or the merits of the products and services referenced herein. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Investments carry risks, including possible loss of principal.

Reference to a fund or security anywhere on this website is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold that or any other security. The information is not a complete analysis of every material fact concerning any market, industry, or investment, nor is it intended to predict the performance of any investment or market.

All opinions and estimates included on this website constitute judgements of Thornburg as at the date of this website and are subject to change without notice.

All information and contents of this website are furnished "as is." Data has been obtained from sources considered reliable, but Thornburg makes no representation as to the completeness or accuracy of such information and has no obligation to provide updates or changes. Thornburg disclaims, to the fullest extent of the law, any implied or express warranty of any kind, including without limitation the implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose and non-infringement.

If you live in a state that does not allow disclaimers of implied warranties, our disclaimer may not apply to you.

Although Thornburg intends the information contained in this website to be accurate and reliable, errors sometimes occur. Thornburg does not warrant that the information to be free of errors, that the functions contained in the site will be uninterrupted, that defects will be corrected or that the site and servers are free from viruses or other harmful components. You agree that you are responsible for the means you use to access this website and understand that your hardware, software, the Internet, your Internet service provider, and other third parties involved in connecting you to our website may not perform as intended or desired. We also disclaim responsibility for damages third parties may cause to you through the use of this website, whether intentional or unintentional. For example, you understand that hackers could breach our security procedures, and that we will not be responsible for any related damages.

Thornburg Investment Management, Inc. is regulated by the U.S. Securities and Exchange under U.S. laws which may differ materially from laws in other jurisdictions.

Online Privacy and Cookie Policy

Please review our Online Privacy and Cookie Policy, which is hereby incorporated by reference as part of these terms and conditions.

Third Party Content

Certain website's content has been obtained from sources that Thornburg believes to be reliable as of the date presented but Thornburg cannot guarantee the accuracy, timeliness, completeness, or suitability for use of such content. The content does not take into account individual investor's circumstances, objectives or needs. The content is not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security or other financial instrument or any investment management services, nor does it constitute investment advice and should not be used as the basis for any investment decision.

Suitability

No determination has been made regarding the suitability of any securities, financial instruments or strategies for any investor. The website's content is provided on the basis and subject to the explanations, caveats and warnings set out in this notice and elsewhere herein. The website's content does not purport to provide any legal, tax or accounting advice. Any discussion of risk management is intended to describe Thornburg's efforts to monitor and manage risk but does not imply low risk.

Limited License and Restrictions on Use

Except as otherwise stated in these terms of use or as expressly authorized by Thornburg in writing, you may not:

  • Modify, copy, distribute, transmit, post, display, perform, reproduce, publish, broadcast, license, create derivative works from, transfer, sell, or exploit any reports, data, information, content, software, RSS and podcast feeds, products, services, or other materials (collectively, "Materials") on, generated by or obtained from this website, whether through links or otherwise;
  • Redeliver any page, text, image or Materials on this website using "framing" or other technology;
  • Engage in any conduct that could damage, disable, or overburden (i) this website, (ii) any Materials or services provided through this website, or (iii) any systems, networks, servers, or accounts related to this website, including without limitation, using devices or software that provide repeated automated access to this website, other than those made generally available by Thornburg;
  • Probe, scan, or test the vulnerability of any Materials, services, systems, networks, servers, or accounts related to this website or attempt to gain unauthorized access to Materials, services, systems, networks, servers, or accounts connected or associated with this website through hacking, password or data mining, or any other means of circumventing any access-limiting, user authentication or security device of any Materials, services, systems, networks, servers, or accounts related to this website; or
  • Modify, copy, obscure, remove or display the Thornburg name, logo, trademarks, notices or images without Thornburg's express written permission. To obtain such permission, you may e-mail us at info@thornburg.com.

Severability, Governing Law

Failure by Thornburg to enforce any provision(s) of these terms and conditions shall not be construed as a waiver of any provision or right. This website is controlled and operated by Thornburg from its offices in Santa Fe, New Mexico. The laws of the State of New Mexico govern these terms and conditions. If you take legal action relating to these terms and conditions, you agree to file such action only in state or federal court in New Mexico and you consent and submit to the personal jurisdiction of those courts for the purposes of litigating any such action.

Termination

You acknowledge and agree that Thornburg may restrict, suspend or terminate these terms and conditions or your access to, and use, of the all or any part this website, including any links to third-party sites, at any time, with or without cause, including but not limited to any breach of these terms and conditions, in Thornburg's absolute discretion and without prior notice or liability.

Decline

Give Us a Call

Fund Operations
800.847.0200

FIND ANOTHER CONTACT
Markets

Old Accounting Methods Undervalue Intangible Assets

Thornburg Investment Management
5 Oct 2020
5 min read

Over time, more value is embedded in intangible assets like software code and so, valuing companies based on tangible assets leads to undervaluation.

Accounting’s Mistreatment of Intangible Assets Distorts Equity Market Valuations:

Intangible assets comprise some four-fifths of S&P 500 companies’ total value, but they don’t show up in balance sheet and valuation analysis unadjusted. About that growth-to-value market rotation…

If the recent speculation about a growth-to-value stock rotation was reinforced in September, when value-classified stocks outperformed growth stocks both in the U.S. and globally, investors now tempted to try and time a leadership shift between the two factors might first consider whether other dynamics may be undermining the strength of the signals reflected in traditional valuation metrics such as price-to-book and price-to-earnings ratios.

After all, a more accurate assessment of a company’s total investment and the potential return on that investment is crucial to gain a better understanding of the company’s earnings potential and return prospects for its shareholders and creditors alike.

The S&P 500 Value Index and the MSCI ACWI Value Index shed 2.3% and 3%, respectively, in the last month of the third quarter, beating their S&P 500 Growth and MSCI ACWI Growth index cousins’ 5.9% and 4.5% losses in the period. Whether an inflection point in index-level style leadership has been reached or it’s yet another headfake, sharper bottom-up analysis can greatly enhance the appraisal of an individual stock’s intrinsic value. That, in turn, improves portfolio construction, regardless of the factor benchmarks into which index providers assign underlying stocks.

Adjustments for anachronistic accounting treatment of investment in both “asset light” new economy stocks and old economy cyclicals can give a far better sense of what nowadays actually constitutes the scale of a company’s investment, the potential return on that investment and greater visibility into future profitability.

To Ensure Against Undervaluing Intangibles, Recognize Value From Investment in Intangible Assets Such as Software Code and Patents

The key, says Thornburg Portfolio Manager Sean Sun in a podcast, is adjusting for investment in intangible assets such as software code, customer lists, licenses, wireless spectrum or other rights, brand equity and sundry types of intellectual property protected by patents and copyrights. While tangible assets are easy to appraise and insure, and show up on the balance sheet, intangibles are harder to measure, insure and show up on the income statement, he points out.

“P/B is what traditional value investors focus on, yet it really only captures tangible assets,” Sun says. “But our economy and our world have been evolving more toward value being embedded in stuff like intellectual property…(and) more digital goods as opposed to physical stuff. When you’re valuing a company purely on tangible book, you’re really missing a whole lot of embedded value.”

Optically Pricey P/B Still Comes Up Short

Source: Bloomberg

The estimated value of intangible assets of S&P 500 Index companies runs at roughly $24 trillion, far greater than the approximately $5 trillion in tangible assets of the blue-chip index constituents.

The Intangible Growth of Real Market Value

Source: Bank of America, AON

Smart private equity firms, Sun adds, certainly adjust for intangible value in acquiring software companies, which often produce extremely valuable streams of cash flow against which leverage can be applied for buyout deals. Indeed, about $121 billion of software deals were done in 2019, he notes.

A corollary is evident in the pharmaceutical industry with Gilead Sciences’ $21 billion acquisition bid for Immunomedics, book value of which runs less than $600 million. Immunomedics, Sun points out, has a cancer drug that can potentially generate between $4 billion and $5 billion in peak sales. The transaction illustrates the nature of “rival” goods, which can only be used by one party at a time, and “non-rival” goods, which can be used by multiple parties simultaneously. A cancer drug, for example, can treat a wide swath of people at the same time while benefitting from patent protection. That “excludability” alongside its non-rival status makes it extremely valuable in a way that traditional book value doesn’t capture, Sun says.

Expensing Intangible Investment on the Income Statement? Sharpen Your Pencil

It also illustrates the value of research and development, which is recorded on the income statement rather than the balance sheet, where capital expenditure shows up. “We all agree that capex is an investment for growth,” Sun says. “We all generally agree that research and development (R&D) is also an investment for growth. But the problem…is that it’s expensed on the income statement as it’s incurred; thus, it doesn’t generate a tangible asset, but it is clearly generating these intangible assets like software code, or patents, or drugs or whatever the case may be, that generate cash flows over time.”

The problem is bigger than most investors may realize, given the sheer scale of investment in R&D compared with capex. According to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, U.S. R&D spending over the last 20 years has been growing at a 4.5% compound annual growth rate, nearly double the 2.4% CAGR in non-financial capex growth.

Growth Drivers in Slow and Fast Lanes

Source: U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, St. Louis Federal Reserve

And it’s not just R&D that conventional accounting is failing to count as an asset. Aspects of sales and marketing and even general and administrative (G&A), which also fall on the income statement, contribute to brand development and customer acquisition. In this respect, they aren’t all just costs but to degrees investment in intangible assets as well. In “SaaS” (software as a service), this is reflected in the customer lifetime value-to-customer acquisition cost ratio. “When lifetime value exceeds the customer acquisition cost by quite a bit, that’s the sign of a really healthy software company,” Sun says.

Network effects on social media, gaming and other types of online platforms create both economies of scale on the supply side and increasing returns on the demand side as the user base grows and monetization opportunities expand. That combination creates a powerful dynamic. But beyond servers, the tangible assets of these companies pale in comparison to their intangible assets.

Active Fund Managers Make Reasonable Adjustments to Clarify Value of Future Cash Flows

Yet for all firms, including old-industry cyclicals, unadjusted P/B ratios can be misleadingly low. “I think it’s important as a fundamental investor to not just look only at the optical metrics but to dig a little deeper,” Sun says. “Make adjustments where it makes sense to capitalize R&D or capitalize parts of sales and marketing or G&A in your pro-forma analysis to get you to what a company is really worth.”

Discover more about:

More Insights

Markets

The Ghosts of Markets Past

We all know that past performance is not an indicator of future results, but how the markets have reacted to events in the past provides valuable perspective.
Economy

What Digitization Means for the Semiconductor Industry

As digitization continues uninterrupted, semiconductor market cycles should become less volatile, still market whipsaws open opportunities for active managers.
Monetary & Fiscal Policy

Fed Tightens as Expected, but the Central Bank Is Not the Only Show

July's 75 bps tightening is important, but overshadowed by PCE and earnings reports.

Our insights. Your inbox.

Sign up to receive timely market commentary and perspectives from our financial experts delivered to your inbox weekly.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.